Energy / WORLD

Analysis: what ICAO's new jatropha and palm defaults mean for aviation fuel

A primary-document review separates ICAO's November land-use update from synthetic-fuel approval claims. Reproducible calculations show why a negative land-use term does not mean carbon-negative jet fuel.

Reading sizeSources ↓Share story ↗
Conceptual illustration of an aircraft, jatropha seeds, palm fruit and layered accounting.Illustration
Symbolic editorial illustration of aviation-fuel feedstocks and life-cycle accounting. It does not depict a real facility, flight, measurement, certification or decision.

ICAO's November 2026 update to aviation-fuel carbon accounting is narrower, and more geographically specific, than a general approval of synthetic kerosene. The authentic amendment adds default indirect land-use-change values for jatropha in sub-Saharan Africa and palm fresh fruit bunches in South America excluding Brazil. For readers assessing fuel projects, the practical question is which feedstock, region and production conditions a value describes—not whether a single international announcement has made every proposed fuel interchangeable.

The amendment history in the ninth edition of CORSIA Default Life Cycle Emissions Values for CORSIA Eligible Fuels records Council approval on 4 November 2026. It identifies a technical conference call on 30 June 2026 as the amendment's source. Those are different milestones. The document is dated November 2026; its month label is not a separately established public release day. Newsverum read the document on 8 November 2026 and uses the recorded approval date as the event date.

For the HEFA conversion process, which converts oils and fats into aviation fuel, Table 9 lists jatropha's new regional land-use terms as -2.8 gCO2e/MJ where the meal is used as fertilizer or an electricity input, and -7.2 gCO2e/MJ where the meal becomes animal feed after detoxification. The palm entry for South America excluding Brazil is -3.4 gCO2e/MJ. These are modelled regulatory defaults tied to specific pathways. They are not measurements from individual plantations, refineries or flights.

The distinction between one component and the complete calculation matters. Section 3.1 sets out lifecycle emissions as core lifecycle emissions plus indirect land-use change, minus applicable emissions credits. Newsverum joined the specified HEFA entries to the document's core-value table and calculated four default-only sums: 44.1 and 39.6 gCO2e/MJ for the two jatropha cases, and 34.0 and 56.6 gCO2e/MJ for two palm cases. The accompanying table preserves the separate inputs so each sum can be reproduced.

All four sums remain positive despite the negative land-use terms. It would therefore be wrong to label these cases carbon-negative jet fuel on the strength of the land-use component. A negative modelled adjustment and removal of carbon from the atmosphere are not interchangeable claims. Nor does an arithmetic total prove that a particular supplier's batch meets every sustainability condition. These calculations explain selected default inputs; they do not certify an operator, a plantation or a fuel delivery.

The palm comparison illustrates how production conditions can matter within the same stated region. The core-value table distinguishes capture and oxidation of at least 85% of biogas from palm oil mill effluent treated in anaerobic ponds from capture below 85%. The corresponding core defaults are 37.4 and 60.0 gCO2e/MJ. Adding the same regional land-use term produces the two different sums above. The comparison isolates a documented condition; it is not an observed estimate of the performance gap between two real producers.

For developers, lenders and fuel buyers, our inference is that a project dossier needs a precise match between its feedstock, location, process and supporting evidence. A regional default should not be applied to Brazil when the entry explicitly excludes Brazil, or silently assigned to a named country without checking its applicability. Likewise, a jatropha pathway specifying detoxified animal feed cannot be treated as the same pathway as meal used for fertilizer or electricity. The source's conditions are part of the number, not optional footnotes.

Historical context also prevents an exaggerated novelty claim. The same amendment table records approval of the eighth edition on 19 November 2025 for a palm-oil-mill-effluent core-value addition. The ninth edition records the subsequent regional land-use additions. This review does not calculate a year-on-year change in those values: the amendment history identifies additions, but it does not supply a matched previous observation for each new regional entry. Absence of an earlier value is missing information, not a zero baseline.

A second distinction concerns the role of the documents. ICAO's current index separately lists the methodology for calculating actual lifecycle emissions as the seventh edition, November 2025. Its fuel guidance distinguishes technical evaluation of conversion pathways by bodies such as ASTM International from CORSIA sustainability eligibility. A carbon-accounting default, technical fuel specification, sustainability certificate and aircraft operating approval answer different questions. This November amendment cannot be used as evidence of blanket commercial certification for unblended power-to-liquid kerosene.

The commercial implications are conditional. A more specifically documented pathway may help an analyst assess how a proposed project would be accounted for, but the document provides no project investment, production cost, sales price, financing commitment, EPC award or airline purchase contract. This analysis therefore assigns none. It also makes no forecast of demand or profitability. A credible project comparison would need independently sourced commercial and operational evidence in addition to the carbon-accounting inputs reviewed here.

Methodology: the table transcribes four core defaults and their matching regional indirect-land-use-change terms from the ninth edition, using the pathway specifications as join keys. Sums use decimal arithmetic, retain one decimal place and apply no optional credits, coal-related correction factors or project-specific direct-land-use-change substitution. Those exclusions define the comparison; they do not assert that such adjustments are zero for any real project. The underlying rows remain modelled defaults and derived calculations rather than observed emissions.

The review is limited to the identified official documents as read on 8 November 2026. It does not reproduce ICAO's underlying land-use models, audit a supply chain or establish current approval for every aircraft and fuel formulation. Newsverum's earlier account that described a new synthetic-kerosene methodology has been visibly corrected and is linked as background. Keeping the actual amendment, the original misstatement and the reproducible calculation separate lets readers judge the evidence without treating an accessible URL, an institutional name or a negative number as sufficient proof.

Data

Table

Selected HEFA modelled defaults and calculated sums

Modelled regulatory defaults, not observed emissions or certified batch values. Negative ILUC terms do not make the positive sums carbon-negative fuel.

Sub-Saharan AfricaHEFA jatropha; meal for fertilizer/electricity46.9-2.844.1Modelled defaults; sum derived by Newsverum
Sub-Saharan AfricaHEFA jatropha; detoxified meal for animal feed46.8-7.239.6Modelled defaults; sum derived by Newsverum
South America excluding BrazilHEFA palm; at least 85% biogas captured and oxidized37.4-3.434Modelled defaults; sum derived by Newsverum
South America excluding BrazilHEFA palm; less than 85% biogas captured and oxidized60-3.456.6Modelled defaults; sum derived by Newsverum
Methodology

ICAO ninth edition, November 2026, Table 2 rows 2.15/2.16/2.11/2.12 joined to Table 9 rows 8.27/8.28/8.29/8.29 by source region and pathway conditions. Decimal(core) + Decimal(ILUC), one decimal place. Excludes optional credits, coal corrections and project-specific DLUC substitution; these are exclusions, not assumed zero project values. No forecast or certification. Read and calculated on 8 November 2026.

Updated:

Structured coverage

Subjects and places

Subject proposals

Taxonomy version: IPTC Media Topics 2026-Q2

Background

Continue reading

Energy

US commercial petroleum stocks rise 11.4 million barrels in week to November 6

EIA reported a broad weekly inventory build as commercial crude, gasoline and distillate stocks increased. Refinery inputs reached 17.0 million barrels per day, while four-week product-supplied averages showed different trends across fuels.

U.S. Energy Information Administration, Weekly Petroleum Status Report landing page for the November 12, 2026 release covering the week ending November 65 min read Data included
Energy

Australia minister reports fuel stocks covering 28 to 41 days

Australia’s climate and energy minister said on 17 October that national stocks represented 41 days of petrol, 33 days of diesel and 28 days of jet fuel. He also described fuel shipments and longer-term government measures.

Australian Minister for Climate Change and Energy1 min read Data included